• Latest
  • Trending
prolife sign

What Pro-Life Feminists Are Arguing in the Mississippi Abortion Case

December 3, 2021
Tony Lowden, Jimmy Carter and Rosalynn Carter's personal pastor, delivered the former first lady eulogy at her funeral on November 29, 2024.

Watch: Tony Lowden, Pastor to Rosalynn Carter and Jimmy Carter, Delivers Former First Lady’s Eulogy

December 1, 2023
aaron dean charged with murder

Zion Carr: Boy Who Witnessed Cop Kill His Aunt Awarded $3.5M Settlement

November 30, 2023
Botham Shem Jean

Sister of Botham Jean — Killed in Home by Off-Duty Cop — Shares Struggles With Forgiveness, Justice in New Book

November 25, 2023
Sandra Maria Van Opstal

‘The Next Worship’ Author Sandra Van Opstal Undergoes Multiple Surgeries to Fight Rare Infection

November 25, 2023
Bishop Carlton Pearson passed away. Carlton Pearson died Sunday, November 19, 2023

Bishop Carlton Pearson, Once Celebrated Pentecostal Preacher, Dies After Brief Battle With Cancer

November 20, 2023
palestinian farmer

‘These Are Biblical Lands Promised to Us,’ Say Jewish Settlers in West Bank Amid Gaza Conflict

November 18, 2023
hans schmidt shot while street preaching near victory chapel church

Victory Chapel Outreach Director Hans Schmidt Shot in Head While Evangelizing Near Church

November 18, 2023
from the river to the sea meaning

Behind the Slogan ‘From the River to the Sea, Palestine Will Be Free’

November 18, 2023
Ayaan Hirsi Ali conversion

Ayaan Hirsi Ali, Outspoken Atheist and ‘Muslim Apostate,’ Says She Is ‘Now a Christian’

November 17, 2023
Breonna Taylor was killed by cops as she was in bed.

Brett Hankison Verdict: Mistrial for Ex-Cop Who Blindly Fired 10 Shots Into Breonna Taylor’s Home

November 17, 2023
Dexter Wade story

Mississippi Man Secretly Buried by Police in Unmarked Grave Had ID With Address Yet Cops Failed to Inform Family

November 17, 2023
arrested in handcuffs

Therapist Specializing in Helping Gay Mormon Men Arrested for Allegedly Sexually Abusing Clients

November 10, 2023
Faithfully Magazine
  • Members
    • Log In
    • Member Home
    • See All Members
    • What’s New
    • Start or Join a Group
    • Your Freebies
Subscribe
No Result
View All Result
  • About
    • Advertise
    • Submit Content
    • Join the Team
    • Contact Us
    • Give Via PayPal
  • Exclusives
  • Q&As
  • Specials
  • NJ News
  • Listen & Watch
  • Shop
    • Faith Heroes Bookmarks
    • Clothing
    • eBooks
  • Events
    • Community Events
    • FM Live Q&As
  • Resources
    • Black Christian Content
  • Newsletter
Cart / $0.00

No products in the cart.

  • About
    • Advertise
    • Submit Content
    • Join the Team
    • Contact Us
    • Give Via PayPal
  • Exclusives
  • Q&As
  • Specials
  • NJ News
  • Listen & Watch
  • Shop
    • Faith Heroes Bookmarks
    • Clothing
    • eBooks
  • Events
    • Community Events
    • FM Live Q&As
  • Resources
    • Black Christian Content
  • Newsletter
No Result
View All Result
Faithfully Magazine
Home Health

What Pro-Life Feminists Are Arguing in the Mississippi Abortion Case

FM Editors by FM Editors
December 3, 2021
in Health, Spotlight, Wellness, Women
Reading Time: 6 mins read
0
prolife sign

(Photo: Maria Oswalt/Unsplash)

45
SHARES
ShareTweetPin It

By Amanda Becker, The 19th

When the U.S. Supreme Court hears oral arguments on Wednesday in a case challenging Mississippi’s 15-week abortion ban, attorneys representing Jackson Women’s Health Organization are expected to argue that abortion access is an enshrined legal right in part because it is essential for gender equality.

But there’s a movement of self-described feminists who believe the opposite to be true.

RelatedArticles

aaron dean charged with murder

Zion Carr: Boy Who Witnessed Cop Kill His Aunt Awarded $3.5M Settlement

November 30, 2023
Sandra Maria Van Opstal

‘The Next Worship’ Author Sandra Van Opstal Undergoes Multiple Surgeries to Fight Rare Infection

November 25, 2023

In an amicus, or friend-of-the-court, brief filed in Dobbs v. Jackson Women’s Health Organization, 240 “women scholars and professionals, and pro-life feminist organizations” present the core tenet of what they call the “pro-life feminist movement”: If abortion is seen as a route to achieve gender equity, they argue, society has less incentive to support pregnancy and the raising of children, thus abortion has hindered, not helped, the cause.

Framing abortion access as essential for equality is an “imprimatur on a male normative experience of reproduction” and has “retarded meaningful accommodation of pregnancy and motherhood in the workplace and other spheres of society,” legal scholars Erika Bachiochi, Helen Alvaré and Teresa Stanton Collett write.

Bachiochi, who directs a project that aims to “support scholarly engagement in questions of sexual identity and freedom” at the Abigail Adams Institute, an independent organization that provides “humanistic” scholarship to the Harvard University community, said the brief’s aim was to show there is no evidence to support claims that abortion access has resulted in better economic outcomes for women. Instead, she said, it has actually justified not doing more to support pregnancy and families.

“We’re wanting more robust family accommodations in the workplace, and really, a market equality between men and women is how feminists talk about equality,” she said in an interview.

Advocates for abortion rights believe safe and legal abortion allows pregnant people to make family-planning and health care decisions that support educational and professional goals, leading to greater gender economic equity.

Support for abortion access has become the formal position of the Democratic Party and most groups advocating for gender equality. The National Organization for Women (NOW) says it “fully supports safe and legal abortion” as a component of “accessible reproductive health care” for women and LGBTQ+ people. The fifth annual Women’s March, held this year, focused on abortion rights after Texas passed its own restrictive law that is the subject of a separate Supreme Court case.

But abortion rights, mainstream feminism and political ideology have not always been so intertwined, according to Mary Ziegler, a legal historian at Florida State University. Ziegler has studied how disagreements over abortion fractured the women’s movement after the Supreme Court’s 1973 decision in Roe v. Wade, which established a constitutional right to abortion. Feminists who oppose abortion have always existed, “they just didn’t tend to be the people who got the microphone” either in the gender equality or anti-abortion movements, Ziegler said.

There are “different strands … of people who self identify as pro-life feminists,” Ziegler said. Some are professionally accomplished conservative women who embrace the feminist label even though it is generally associated with the progressive movement. Others are more liberal than typical abortion opponents and support issues such as contraception access and increased spending on social programs like health care and paid leave.

Self-identified feminists who oppose most or all abortions often straddle different worlds, completely at home neither in the broader conservative anti-abortion movement nor in liberal groups that believe feminism requires supporting abortion access and a commitment to Roe. Over the past 50 years, dozens of feminist organizations that oppose abortion have formed that aim to provide an ideological home.

Among the groups that signed the “pro-life feminist” amicus brief are Secular Pro-Life, a group led by atheist women — one politically conservative, one moderate, one liberal — that opposes elective abortion, supports contraception, and does not take an official position on abortion in cases of rape or incest. Another is Feminists for Nonviolent Choices, a “consistent life” organization that opposes abortion and capital punishment and advocates for better working conditions and fair housing. New Wave Feminists promotes nonviolence from “womb to tomb,” with a focus on immigration, racial justice, human trafficking, and pre- and post-natal care.

New Wave Feminists President Destiny Herndon-De La Rosa said the group started 15 years ago as a MySpace page and evolved into a national organization. Its members are “all over the place politically” and come from a variety of religious backgrounds, including atheism and agnosticism. The group doesn’t typically focus on the legality or illegality of abortion, but decided to sign onto the Dobbs brief because its framing made it a “vital part of the conversation” about abortion and gender equality, she said.

“We want to expose the fact that so many women don’t actually have a choice when it comes to making an abortion decision because of the systemic patriarchy that says to operate and succeed in a man’s world, your fertility will make you a liability,” Herndon-De La Rosa said.

Brief author Bachiochi supported abortion rights when she was a women’s studies student at a small liberal arts college in Vermont. She was left-leaning and volunteered for now-Sen. Bernie Sanders. But her thinking evolved as she earned a master’s in theology, then a law degree. She studied early suffragists such as Victoria Woodhull, who ran for president before women could vote and wrote in 1870 that it was “murder to destroy life in its embryonic condition.” The center Bachiochi now heads is named for Mary Wollstonecraft, a British philosopher in the 1700s who advocated for women’s rights and whose writings can be interpreted as opposing abortion.

“One thing they believed … is there is also a way in which abortion, especially readily available abortion, tilts the playing field further in the male direction” by not supporting women’s autonomy more broadly, Bachiochi said of some of the earliest women’s rights activists.

Co-authors Collett and Alvaré have more traditional politically conservative backgrounds. Collett directs the Prolife Center at St. Thomas University, a Catholic college in Minnesota, and gives regular talks about women’s equality via organizations such as the Federalist Society and the Heritage Foundation. Alvaré teaches family law at the conservative-leaning George Mason University and represented the U.S. Conference of Catholic Bishops on anti-abortion issues in the early 1990s. Both have opposed marriage equality.

Collett said that among anti-abortion feminists there is a “broad and deep consensus that families, particularly families experiencing pregnancy and raising young children, need a support network.” Alvaré said that women who identify as feminist but oppose abortion are “tired of being condescended to” by people who don’t understand how the two fit together.

The Supreme Court decided Roe based not on abortion’s impact on gender equality but on an implied right to privacy in multiple constitutional amendments. It upheld that right in its 5-4 decision in Casey v. Planned Parenthood in 1992, finding that “the ability of women to participate equally in the economic and social life of the Nation has been facilitated by their ability to control their reproductive lives.”

In 2007, when the court voted 5-4 to allow the Partial Birth Abortion Ban Act of 2003 to remain in effect, then-Justice Ruth Bader Ginsburg wrote in a dissent that “legal challenges to undue restrictions on abortion procedures do not seek to vindicate some generalized notion of privacy; rather, they center on a woman’s autonomy to determine her life’s course, and thus to enjoy equal citizenship stature.”

Ginsburg was a staunch supporter of abortion access but believed the legal right to end a pregnancy was best established by the Constitution’s promise of equal protection, not privacy. Ziegler predicted in 2013 that Ginsburg’s 2007 dissent could result in other liberals on the court being more willing to openly support equality-based abortion-rights claims — and that “pro-life feminists have promoted an important counterargument” worth examination. The dynamic is playing out in the Dobbs case.

Lawyers representing Jackson Women’s Health Organization said in their pre-trial brief that preserving abortion access is “critical to women’s equality” in part because they “may lose educational opportunities” and “face decreased opportunities to pursue their full career potential.” They could therefore be “more likely to experience economic insecurity,” the lawyers argue.

Bachiochi, Alvaré and Collett counter that “there are innumerable other factors that contributed to women’s social and economic equality, as well as evidence that abortion has actively harmed women and their progress.”

“These arguments tend, unwittingly perhaps, to promote the male childless norm in educational and employment settings,” they write.

They argue there is “simply no causal link between the availability of abortion the the ‘capacity of women to act in society,’” pointing to data showing how more women continued to enroll in college, participated in the workforce and ran for elected office even as abortion rates declined starting in the 1990s.

“The pro-life feminists brief in Dobbs is saying: ‘OK, even if you don’t like the privacy arguments that are the original basis for Roe, the equality arguments you’re getting from some people on the other side don’t work,” Ziegler told The 19th.

Editor’s note: This article was originally published by The 19th.

Leave your vote

0 Points
Upvote Downvote

Browse and manage your votes from your Member Profile Page


Share This Post

Share via

Share This Post

  • Digg
  • Tumblr
  • Flipboard
  • SMS
More
  • Report
Advertisement
Ancestry US
45
SHARES
ShareTweetPin It
FM Editors

FM Editors

Faithfully Magazine is a fresh, bold and exciting news and culture publication that covers issues, conversations and events impacting Christian communities of color.

More Articles

abortion
Wellness

Provocative Abortion Clinic Opens in Bible Belt

March 20, 2017
African American Woman
Features

A Look Inside The Growing Black Pro-Life Movement

December 21, 2017
handcuffs
Crime

Mom and Daugher Plead Guilty to Running $20 Million Medicare Scam

March 7, 2017

Discussion about this post

Upcoming Events

Dec 13
6:30 pm - 7:30 pm EST

Event: ‘Framing the News: Can Humanities Build Audience Engagement?’

View Calendar

Trending

  • Trending
  • Comments
  • Latest
Tony Evans and Carla Crummie engaged to be married

Dr. Tony Evans Engaged to Former Pastor’s Wife and Widow Four Years After Lois Evans’ Death

September 12, 2023
Sandra Maria Van Opstal

‘The Next Worship’ Author Sandra Van Opstal Undergoes Multiple Surgeries to Fight Rare Infection

November 25, 2023
Christian Cultural Center

5 Largest Churches in New York City

May 29, 2018
Bishop Carlton Pearson passed away. Carlton Pearson died Sunday, November 19, 2023

Bishop Carlton Pearson, Once Celebrated Pentecostal Preacher, Dies After Brief Battle With Cancer

November 20, 2023
stream movies laptop

Free Christian Movies: How and Where to Watch Free Christian Movies Online

March 15, 2021
jackie hill perry tbn fruits of the spirit heterosexuality

Sexuality Has Nothing to Do With Salvation, Jackie Hill Perry Says in TBN Talk About ‘Gay Girl, Good God’

October 8, 2021
Tony Lowden, Jimmy Carter and Rosalynn Carter's personal pastor, delivered the former first lady eulogy at her funeral on November 29, 2024.

Watch: Tony Lowden, Pastor to Rosalynn Carter and Jimmy Carter, Delivers Former First Lady’s Eulogy

December 1, 2023
aaron dean charged with murder

Zion Carr: Boy Who Witnessed Cop Kill His Aunt Awarded $3.5M Settlement

November 30, 2023
Botham Shem Jean

Sister of Botham Jean — Killed in Home by Off-Duty Cop — Shares Struggles With Forgiveness, Justice in New Book

November 25, 2023
Sandra Maria Van Opstal

‘The Next Worship’ Author Sandra Van Opstal Undergoes Multiple Surgeries to Fight Rare Infection

November 25, 2023
Bishop Carlton Pearson passed away. Carlton Pearson died Sunday, November 19, 2023

Bishop Carlton Pearson, Once Celebrated Pentecostal Preacher, Dies After Brief Battle With Cancer

November 20, 2023
palestinian farmer

‘These Are Biblical Lands Promised to Us,’ Say Jewish Settlers in West Bank Amid Gaza Conflict

November 18, 2023

Most Shared Articles

  • ‘The Next Worship’ Author Sandra Van Opstal Undergoes Multiple Surgeries to Fight Rare I...
  • Bishop Carlton Pearson, Once Celebrated Pentecostal Preacher, Dies After Brief Battle With Cancer...
  • Victory Chapel Outreach Director Hans Schmidt Shot in Head While Evangelizing Near Church...
  • ‘Gospel of Inclusion’ Preacher Bishop Carlton Pearson Enters Comfort Care Amid Recurrent...
  • Tye Tribbett Makes Reunion Tour Appearance After Being Rushed to Hospital for Minor Surgery...

From The Archive

MLK Character Quote
Inspiration

Divisive Like Jesus: Calling Out Racism and Interpreting the Times

by Lamar Hardwick
July 18, 2019
sandra miller rick miller
Clippings

Christian School Fires Sandra Miller After Her Racist, Anti-Asian Tirade Goes Viral

by FM Editors
February 5, 2022
Ron DeSantis
Opinion & Analysis

DeSantis’ ‘War on Woke’ Similar to Attempts by Other Countries to Deny and Rewrite History

by FM Editors
July 28, 2023
Jackie Hill Perry
Books

Interview: Jackie Hill Perry Talks ‘Gay Girl, Good God,’ Same-Sex Attraction, and Why Conversion Therapy Is ‘Silly’

by FM Editors
September 28, 2018
church worship
Books

8 Unpopular Truths About US Christianity, According to Jemar Tisby’s ‘The Color of Compromise’

by Chante Griffin
March 29, 2019

Who’s Online

There are no users currently online

Latest Votes

  • FM Editors on

    Jesus Likely Had Olive Skin and Short Black Hair, But What Did He Wear?

  • valexander on

    Christena Cleveland on ‘God Is a Black Woman’ and What Compelled Her to ‘Step off the Plantation’

  • FM Editors on

    Sexuality Has Nothing to Do With Salvation, Jackie Hill Perry Says in TBN Talk About ‘Gay Girl, Good God’

Facebook Twitter Youtube Instagram
Faithfully Magazine

Faithfully Magazine is a news and culture publication centered on Christian communities of color.

We participate in various affiliate programs that allow us to earn fees by linking to affiliated sites. FM is independently owned and published and is supported by digital subscriptions, advertising, merchandise sales, and affiliate links. We use these funds to maintain operations and pay our writers. Donations are welcomed.

Recent News

  • Watch: Tony Lowden, Pastor to Rosalynn Carter and Jimmy Carter, Delivers Former First Lady’s Eulogy
  • Zion Carr: Boy Who Witnessed Cop Kill His Aunt Awarded $3.5M Settlement
  • Sister of Botham Jean — Killed in Home by Off-Duty Cop — Shares Struggles With Forgiveness, Justice in New Book
  • ‘The Next Worship’ Author Sandra Van Opstal Undergoes Multiple Surgeries to Fight Rare Infection

Most Shared Posts

  • ‘The Next Worship’ Author Sandra Van Opstal Undergoes Multiple Surgeries to Fight Rare Infection...
  • Bishop Carlton Pearson, Once Celebrated Pentecostal Preacher, Dies After Brief Battle With Cancer...
  • Victory Chapel Outreach Director Hans Schmidt Shot in Head While Evangelizing Near Church...
  • ‘Gospel of Inclusion’ Preacher Bishop Carlton Pearson Enters Comfort Care Amid Recurrent Cancer...
  • Tye Tribbett Makes Reunion Tour Appearance After Being Rushed to Hospital for Minor Surgery...

© 2023 Faithfully Media, LLC (Owner and Operator)

  • From The Magazine
  • Inspiration
  • News
  • Opinion & Analysis
  • Profiled
  • Q&As
  • Remember
  • Specials
  • New Jersey
  • Listen & Watch
  • Web Exclusives
  • Shop
    • Clothing
    • Faith Heroes Bookmarks
    • eBooks
  • Events
    • FM Live Events
    • Community Events
  • Resources
    • Black Christian Content
  • About Us
    • Advertise With Us
    • Submit Content
    • Join the Editorial Team
    • Give Via PayPal
  • Members
    • Log In
    • Your Freebies
  • Subscribe to Faithfully Magazine
  • Newsletter
No Result
View All Result

© 2023 Faithfully Media, LLC (Owner and Operator)

Welcome Back!

Login to your account below

Forgotten Password? Sign Up

Create New Account!

Fill the forms bellow to register

*By registering on our website, you agree to the Terms & Conditions and Privacy Policy.
All fields are required. Log In

Retrieve your password

Please enter your username or email address to reset your password.

Log In
Share via

Share This Post

  • Twitter
  • Facebook
  • Reddit
  • Email
  • WhatsApp
  • Copy Link
  • Tumblr
  • Digg
  • Flipboard
  • SMS

Add New Playlist

Log In

Sign In

Login with Facebook
Login with Twitter
Forgot password?

Don't have an account? Register

Forgot password?

Enter your account data and we will send you a link to reset your password.

Back to Login

Your password reset link appears to be invalid or expired.

Log in

Privacy Policy

Accept

Add to Collection

  • Public collection title

  • Private collection title

No Collections

Here you'll find all collections you've created before.

Try a 14-day free trial today with Ancestry® (We may earn a commission) Dismiss

This website uses cookies. By continuing to use this website you are giving consent to cookies being used. Visit our Privacy and Cookie Policy.
Are you sure want to unlock this post?
Unlock left : 0
Are you sure want to cancel subscription?

Warning: array_sum() expects parameter 1 to be array, null given in /home/customer/www/faithfullymagazine.com/public_html/wp-content/plugins/jnews-social-share/class.jnews-social-background-process.php on line 112
Send this to a friend