ADVERTISEMENT
Faithfully Magazine
  • News
    • All
    • Crime
    • Politics
    • World
    Mass at Sacred Heart Church in Uvalde after a gunman killed 19 children and two teachers at nearby Robb Elementary School.

    Texas Agencies Resist Releasing Public Records on Uvalde School Shooting

    juneteenth on a flag

    Juneteenth Is a Federal Holiday: Here’s What You Need to Know

    Salvador Ramos, identified as the gunman who killed 19 students and teachers Robb Elementary in Uvalde, Texas May 24, 2022

    ‘It’s Time to Die,’ Uvalde Shooter Salvador Ramos Told Schoolchildren Before Opening Fire

    Reverend Mark Hatcher

    Philadelphia Pastor Accused of Child Rape Deemed ‘Danger to the Community’

  • Clippings
    Harry Knoesen

    Pastor Plotted to Kill Thousands of Black People, Overthrow South African Government

    The tabernacle, which is pure 18-karat gold, dates back to the 1890s, according to the Diocese of Brooklyn

    19th-Century Tabernacle Worth $2M Stolen From Church in ‘Brazen Crime of Disrespect and Hate’

    Fermin Rangel-Ramos

    Pastor Kicked Out of Church After 11 Accuse Him of Abuse to Serve At Least One Year in Prison

    rapper M.I.A.

    Rapper M.I.A. Says She’s a Born-Again Christian After Seeing ‘Vision of Jesus Christ’

  • Features
    Mass at Sacred Heart Church in Uvalde after a gunman killed 19 children and two teachers at nearby Robb Elementary School.

    Texas Agencies Resist Releasing Public Records on Uvalde School Shooting

    Celia Lewis ProPublica

    White Anti-CRT Parents Got a Black Educator Fired, Then Chased Her to Her Next Job

    Tops Friendly Markets in Buffalo, New York

    Overtly White Supremacist Ideology Is Being Sanitized and Mainstreamed

    children in a classroom getting education

    On Race and Schools, Here’s What Americans Agree and Disagree On

  • Inspiration
    • All
    • Bible
    • First-Person Essay
    • Poetry
    Everything Everywhere All At Once. (A24 Films)

    ‘Everything Everywhere All At Once’ & the Absurdity of Love as Resistance

    God Speaks Through Wombs: Poems on God's Unexpected Coming

    The Gospels Give Birth to Poetry (‘God Speaks Through Wombs’ Excerpt)

    two women talk

    100 Proverbs That Teach Us How to Speak, Listen, and Respectfully Disagree

    Rapper J Cole and a hanging tree

    J. Cole’s ‘Javari,’ the Cross, and the Lynching Tree

  • Members
  • About Us
    • Staff and Advisors
    • Write for Us
    • Advertise With Us
SUBSCRIBE
No Result
View All Result
  • News
    • All
    • Crime
    • Politics
    • World
    Mass at Sacred Heart Church in Uvalde after a gunman killed 19 children and two teachers at nearby Robb Elementary School.

    Texas Agencies Resist Releasing Public Records on Uvalde School Shooting

    juneteenth on a flag

    Juneteenth Is a Federal Holiday: Here’s What You Need to Know

    Salvador Ramos, identified as the gunman who killed 19 students and teachers Robb Elementary in Uvalde, Texas May 24, 2022

    ‘It’s Time to Die,’ Uvalde Shooter Salvador Ramos Told Schoolchildren Before Opening Fire

    Reverend Mark Hatcher

    Philadelphia Pastor Accused of Child Rape Deemed ‘Danger to the Community’

  • Clippings
    Harry Knoesen

    Pastor Plotted to Kill Thousands of Black People, Overthrow South African Government

    The tabernacle, which is pure 18-karat gold, dates back to the 1890s, according to the Diocese of Brooklyn

    19th-Century Tabernacle Worth $2M Stolen From Church in ‘Brazen Crime of Disrespect and Hate’

    Fermin Rangel-Ramos

    Pastor Kicked Out of Church After 11 Accuse Him of Abuse to Serve At Least One Year in Prison

    rapper M.I.A.

    Rapper M.I.A. Says She’s a Born-Again Christian After Seeing ‘Vision of Jesus Christ’

  • Features
    Mass at Sacred Heart Church in Uvalde after a gunman killed 19 children and two teachers at nearby Robb Elementary School.

    Texas Agencies Resist Releasing Public Records on Uvalde School Shooting

    Celia Lewis ProPublica

    White Anti-CRT Parents Got a Black Educator Fired, Then Chased Her to Her Next Job

    Tops Friendly Markets in Buffalo, New York

    Overtly White Supremacist Ideology Is Being Sanitized and Mainstreamed

    children in a classroom getting education

    On Race and Schools, Here’s What Americans Agree and Disagree On

  • Inspiration
    • All
    • Bible
    • First-Person Essay
    • Poetry
    Everything Everywhere All At Once. (A24 Films)

    ‘Everything Everywhere All At Once’ & the Absurdity of Love as Resistance

    God Speaks Through Wombs: Poems on God's Unexpected Coming

    The Gospels Give Birth to Poetry (‘God Speaks Through Wombs’ Excerpt)

    two women talk

    100 Proverbs That Teach Us How to Speak, Listen, and Respectfully Disagree

    Rapper J Cole and a hanging tree

    J. Cole’s ‘Javari,’ the Cross, and the Lynching Tree

  • Members
  • About Us
    • Staff and Advisors
    • Write for Us
    • Advertise With Us
No Result
View All Result
Faithfully Magazine
No Result
View All Result

A Tale of Two Machens: How a Christian ‘Hero’ Let White Privilege Color His Theology

Timothy I. Cho by Timothy I. Cho
September 8, 2018
in Churches, Features, Web Exclusives
Reading Time: 6 mins read
0
J Gresham Machen Faithfully Magazine

J. Gresham Machen. (Photo: Wikimedia Commons/Public Domain)

Share on FacebookShare on TwitterShare on RedditShare on LinkedInEmail This
323
SHARES
ShareTweetPin It

A hero to many within Reformed and conservative Evangelical circles, J. Gresham Machen is often depicted as an exemplary theologian with an unwavering devotion to biblical orthodoxy. Yet, a key historical document shows that this hero of the Christian faith allowed white supremacy to redefine, reshape, and even undo tenets of the gospel.

The Dominant Narrative

Few names are more significant in the narrative of conservative American Christianity than J. Gresham Machen. For those who are unfamiliar with the name, Machen was an American Presbyterian theologian in the early 20th century who was highly influential during the Fundamentalist-Modernist Controversy that splintered denominations throughout the United States. In particular, Machen is often considered as a stalwart of theological conservatism, as someone who stood for truth against the rising tide of theological liberalism in his Presbyterian denomination and Reformed seminary. He pointedly states in his book, Christianity and Liberalism, that there was a fundamental and irreparable rift between the historic Christian faith and what he identified as a theologically liberal movement that readily denied fundamentals of the Christian faith, such as the virgin birth, miracles, and the resurrection.

Mosaic Coffee
Machen Hall at Westminster Theological Seminary
Photo of Machen Hall at Westminster Theological Seminary (Photo: Wikimedia Commons)

As his own denomination and seminary shifted toward the rising liberalism of the day, Machen dug in his heels to stand for orthodoxy until he led a conservative base to form a new denomination, the Orthodox Presbyterian Church (OPC), and a new seminary, Westminster Theological Seminary (WTS). This base was distinctly and robustly Reformed and conservative in its theology. Machen’s influence is seen throughout both the Reformed and conservative Evangelical landscapes. A hero to many within these circles, Machen is often depicted as an exemplary theologian with an unwavering devotion to biblical orthodoxy.

RELATED STORIES

The Real ‘Great Replacement’: When Resentful Whites Recruited Foreigners to Undermine Black Progress

Overtly White Supremacist Ideology Is Being Sanitized and Mainstreamed

This was the narrative that I had been told as a longtime member in the OPC and as a student in an institution that shares its name with WTS. Yet, through personal research in a desire to know the truth about the past to the best of my ability, I discovered that this narrative has an entirely different and rarely acknowledged side.[emaillocker id=60875]

The Hidden Narrative

In a letter addressed to his mother dated October 5, 1913, Machen writes about a tumultuous development at Princeton Theological Seminary: a “colored man” was planned to be integrated into the seminary dormitory.*

“…any time a room is vacant [the colored man] may move over here. If I am to make any objection, now is the time to make it. Of course if he came over here I could simply move out. It would be a big sacrifice to me.”

In his letter, Machen explains that he “most emphatically objects” to the integration of people of color in the dorms because “the intimacy of the relation of the men in the same dormitory where there is only one bath-room, exceeds, in some respects, at least, that of table-companionship.”

In fact, Machen alludes to the “separate but equal” principle from the infamous Plessy v. Ferguson Supreme Court ruling to make the claim that “the case is not as though [Princeton Seminary] were the only place which [Blacks] could come if they are to be educated for the ministry,” citing historically Black theological institutions in existence during that time.

Benjamin Warfield
Portrait of B.B. Warfield (Photo: Wikimedia Commons)

Furthermore, Machen claims that his views were not unique among the faculty at Princeton: “I have talked to a number of members of the faculty…They all sympathize fully with me, [] to Dr. Warfield himself, not a single member of the faculty agrees with him.” Benjamin Breckinridge Warfield, the head of Princeton Seminary at the time, is known for his writings against slavery and segregation. Machen writes of a two-hour argument with Warfield regarding the integration of the Princeton Seminary dormitories, of which he claims, “My total impression was that, despite his remarkable gifts… [Warfield] is bitterly lacking in appreciation of the facts of human nature.”

Lastly, while Machen claims that the faculty agrees with him about keeping the dormitories segregated, he makes note that some of these professors have been “sticklers” for the civil rights of Blacks, and that equal rights for Blacks is dangerous to the livelihood of White men:

“It is true some of them are ‘sticklers’ for the civil rights of negroes – it always makes me intensely angry to hear people talking glibly about equal civil rights of negroes when in many parts of the South those equal rights would mean that every legislator and every judge would be a savage of a [] type and the white men would be more unsafe in parts of this country than in the most [] parts of the world where at least the protection of his home government is to some extent with him.”

White Theology Unmasked

While this is a private letter between Machen and his mother, the events and actions mentioned in the letter are anything but private. Machen’s stance on segregation is perfectly clear, and this adds an entirely new layer to the narrative about him. He was not simply a stalwart of Reformed and conservative theology, but also a vocal and public defender of segregation and thought negatively of the civil rights of an entire group of fellow image-bearers. His actions had broad institutional and systemic impacts in the seminary and beyond.

Furthermore, his feelings and actions surrounding this topics of segregation and civil rights was anything but non-theological or theologically neutral. This is a clear example of a man who allowed his cultural captivity to redefine, reshape, and even undo tenets of the gospel at the core of the Christian faith. White theology is simply this—the re-crafting of the Christian faith and the gospel itself to accommodate to the preferentiality, privilege, normalcy, and even supremacy of the self-invented status of whiteness. The Christian faith was molded into Machen’s ideals of how he thought the world should operate and how people groups should or should not relate to one another. His confessional theology (what he said he believed) and his practical, experiential theology (what he lived out in the day-to-day) was never more clearly divorced than in this occasion.

Robert Lewis Dabney
Portrait of R.L. Dabney, Reformed theologian, pastor, and staunch defender of slavery. (Photo: Wikimedia Commons)

Nevertheless, Machen is an example of how some White Christians allowed their whiteness and desire to protect their privileged status to blemish and skew the gospel and undermine the scandal of the cross. If his claims are correct, Machen’s whole faculty less one was on his side in this matter on segregation. White theology has a long-standing track record of protecting an invented status of whiteness at the expense of another invented status of non-whiteness. White theology made it church practice and policy to deem the baptism of enslaved peoples as inferior to the baptism of their masters. White theology not only enslaved, colonized, and dehumanized, but it also found these heinous acts to be perfectly reconcilable with confessing Jesus as Lord and Savior.

Perhaps the most insidious fact of White theology, though, is that it thrives in hiding or twisting the truth to protect itself from honest and fair criticism. It is not only Machen, but many White and European theologians in Reformed and conservative Evangelical circles are often portrayed as the default and definitive voices of all good, objective, and unbiased theology. Non-White Christian voices are seen as superfluous at best or theologically spurious at worst. Alleged or actual moral failings by theologians of color are used to question their orthodoxy, while sins of the same substance by White theologians are explained away due to being “a product of their times.”

Toward an Honest Narrative

The fact that Machen held to theological orthodoxy on the one hand while firmly holding to segregationist convictions on the other should cause all of us to pause and think about how we tell the story of our own theological heroes and heroines, as well as who we consider as our theological adversaries. It should make us consider if we have wrongly pedestaled those in our own tribes while unfairly putting down others. Have we inculcated an atmosphere of spiritual and theological hubris? Have we told the narrative as honestly as possible, or have we hidden facts that inconveniently undermine our positions of credibility and authority? Christians, as those who believe that the truth will set us free, should be more than willing and eager to tell history as honestly as possible—the good, the bad, and the ugly. It is only then that we can appreciate truth wherever it’s told and lament sin wherever it’s found.


*Source: Machen, J.Gresham. “Machen to Mother.” Received by Timothy Isaiah Cho from the Archives of Montgomery Library at Westminster Theological Seminary, 5 October 1913.

[/emaillocker]

Leave your vote

1 Point
Upvote Downvote

Browse and manage your votes from your Member Profile Page

What's Your Reaction?

  • AngryAngry
    2
    Angry
  • CuteCute
    0
    Cute
  • CryCry
    0
    Cry
  • LOLLOL
    2
    LOL
  • LoveLove
    0
    Love
  • OMGOMG
    2
    OMG

REPRINT REQUESTS | MEMBERSHIPS | GIVE



Share This Post

Share via

Share This Post

  • Digg
  • Tumblr
  • Flipboard
  • SMS
More
  • Report
323
SHARES
ShareTweetPin It
Timothy I. Cho

Timothy I. Cho

Timothy Isaiah Cho is Associate Editor at Faithfully Magazine. Timothy’s bylines have appeared in Religion News Service and Reformed Margins, and he has been interviewed for several podcasts including Truth’s Table and Gravity Leadership Podcast. He also runs a personal blog on Medium. He received a Master of Divinity from Westminster Seminary California and a Bachelor of Arts in English Literature from U.C. Berkeley. Email: timothy.cho (at) faithfullymagazine.com

Related Posts

A business at 314 Broad Street in Leland, Mississippi, as seen on January 1, 1939

The Real ‘Great Replacement’: When Resentful Whites Recruited Foreigners to Undermine Black Progress

Tops Friendly Markets in Buffalo, New York

Overtly White Supremacist Ideology Is Being Sanitized and Mainstreamed

Unlearning Racism As a Non-Black Person of Color

Christians Called to Face the ‘Whole…Dark Truth’ About Church’s Role in Indian Boarding School System

Upcoming Live Events

There are no upcoming Events at this time.

Recently Published

  • ‘Truth’s Table’ Authors Talk Early Beginnings, Centering Black Women, and Inspiring One Another
  • Texas Agencies Resist Releasing Public Records on Uvalde School Shooting
  • Why We Need Nurturing Fathers
  • White Anti-CRT Parents Got a Black Educator Fired, Then Chased Her to Her Next Job
  • Juneteenth Is a Federal Holiday: Here’s What You Need to Know
Mosaic Coffee
  • Privacy Policy
  • Contact Us
  • Shop
  • Newsletter

© 2022 Faithfully Media LLC, owner and operator. All rights reserved. This site participates in the Amazon Associates program, and other affiliate programs, and may earn a commission from your purchases.

No Result
View All Result
  • News
  • Clippings
  • Features
  • Spotlight
  • Inspiration
  • Log In
    • Your Profile
Share via

Share This Post

  • Twitter
  • Facebook
  • Reddit
  • Email
  • WhatsApp
  • Copy Link
  • Tumblr
  • Digg
  • Flipboard
  • SMS
close

Log In

Sign In

Login with Facebook
Login with Twitter
Forgot password?

Don't have an account? Register

Forgot password?

Enter your account data and we will send you a link to reset your password.

Back to Login

Your password reset link appears to be invalid or expired.

Log in

Privacy Policy

Accept

Add to Collection

  • Public collection title

  • Private collection title

No Collections

Here you'll find all collections you've created before.

This website uses cookies. By continuing to use this website you are giving consent to cookies being used. Visit our Privacy and Cookie Policy.
Send this to a friend