When a Pastor Becomes a Politician

Share

I was nine years old when I participated in my first political march, and it was a walk in the park — literally. We were protesting the removal of a religious monument in a public park, a hot-button issue plastered across my community via yard signs. When the monument was finally removed, 13 people were arrested, including the couple who taught children’s church.

The event made national news, with our pastor at the forefront of it all. He was the one who organized the protest. He was the one who lit a fire in his congregation to take the fight to the Capitol. He was the one they always quoted in the newspapers. It was a stunning transformation that began with a subtle shift in focus: away from Jesus Christ and onto himself.

It didn’t happen overnight. Before he was organizing marches, serving as chaplain of the state senate, and writing columns for a local newspaper, he was simply a pastor focused on growing a home church into a congregation of more than 400. But somewhere along the way, his passion for politics overtook his passion for preaching. His penchant for phrasing political issues in headline-grabbing ways made him a favorite of local journalists, and he enjoyed the attention. Soon, our pastor was spending more time talking about politics than theology, and he was unavailable to his congregation from Monday to Saturday. When our elder board asked him to be more involved, he refused. A week later, he was fired.

This isn’t to say that faith and politics should never intersect. Pastors and religious leaders spearheaded the greatest political movements in American history, including abolition, suffrage, and civil rights. The pulpit can be a powerful force for justice. But there is a profound difference between preaching about political issues through the lens of Scripture and preaching about Scripture through the lens of politics. When the latter happens, every sermon becomes a stump speech. A message on Nehemiah becomes a thinly veiled argument for a border wall; a lesson on the Ethiopian eunuch devolves into a debate on queer theory. Politics, at its core, is a competition that creates an “us vs. them” dynamic. While Jesus breaks down walls of division, this kind of preaching builds them back up, fracturing the very unity a pastor is called to foster.

Ultimately, a pastor who becomes a politician is forced to choose politics over his parishioners. I saw it with my own pastor, and I see it in stories like that of Rev. Jonathan Barker. When the Evangelical Lutheran Church in America told Barker he could not endorse Alexandria Ocasio-Cortez during a service, he was faced with a choice. He resigned. A church member told the Chicago Sun-Times that Barker simply “couldn’t put politics aside.” Neither could my former pastor. He eventually left the state to become a prominent voice on right-wing radio, likely never to pastor a church again.

The tragedy is that when a pastor becomes a politician, he loses sight of his primary responsibility. Jesus’ command to Peter wasn’t to acquire worldly power or lead protests, but simply to “feed my sheep.” We can get political opinions from countless podcasts, pundits, and politicians. But what none of them can offer is spiritual food. The purpose of a Sunday sermon is to feed the flock. The purpose of marital counseling is to tend to the flock. The purpose of showing up in a hospital room at three in the morning is to comfort the flock. When a pastor becomes a politician, the Sunday service just feels like another campaign stop, and the sheep are left to go hungry.

Editor’s note: This article was refined with the help of an AI editing tool.


Kyle Morgan
Kyle Morgan
Kyle Morgan has been published in The Old Schoolhouse Magazine, The Caldwell Perspective, and is a monthly blogger for Write2Ignite: a website for Christian children’s authors. He graduated from Grand Canyon University in 2025 with a degree in Professional Writing for New Media. You can find him on Instagram and Facebook, @KyleMorganAuthor.

Read more

Trending